Zwitter trafficators / semifore / semiphore thingys

[ZwitterND]

Need help from a semifore / trafficator guru. What is the correct semifore for a zwitter. My parts book says 953 021a or 15 953 021. Below are the two that came with the car which I am assuming must be replacements. The left one is 111 953 021C and right one is 111 953 021F. The other confusing issue is the picture in the parts book shows the ribbed style. I am so confused

_________________
Bill

[johnshenry]

Neither are correct IMO. I think there is evidence that ribbed and grooved were used until the end of '53, and the "3 x 3" numbering scheme was used until late '53 or '54. So 3 x 3 numbered smoothies are not correct for a Zwitter.

I think zwitters would have had either ribbed or grooved, with L numbered parts. If ribbed (SWF) possibly the "improved" version of them without the sliding bulb contact door and the with the longer nosed ribbed arm cover. They should at least be the single screw kind.

Still much mystery about those "long nose" SWFs, but ribbed or grooved for sure on a Zwit.
_________________
John Henry

'57 Deluxe
'56 Single Cab

[73sports]

Here are a couple of shots of the original semaphores from my 11/52 zwitter.

_________________
I will never lie, but sometimes the truth changes.

Central Jersey VW Society

[ZwitterND]

Oh crap why do I know this is going cost me, Who said zwitters are the poor man's split was right....I am going to be poor after this restoration. My zwitter is 11/52. Personally I like the smooth but I want to make it original. Now your part numbers differ from the book. And why does the book give two? Who was running this outfit?? OK who has some and which organ do you need?

_________________
Bill

[johnshenry]

VW assigned 3 x 3 numbers to the ribbed and grooved after 53/54 as they continued to make them as replacement parts after they started using the smooth ones in production (perhaps those are the numbers in the book). Not sure how long they did this, as I'm certain that it wasn't long before someone figured out "hey, just put the smooth ones in there, and 'upgrade' the car'".

What year is that parts catalog from? Note that it shows the single screw ribbed sem in the drawing.

I have seen about as many 3 x 3 numbered ribbed SWFs as I have L numbered. The L numbered ones are worth more IMO for "those purists".

I have a set of both the SWF ribbed "long nose" ones in the classifieds, as well as a set of grooved SHOs.

http://www.thesamba.com/vw/classifieds/detail.php?id=876930
http://www.thesamba.com/vw/classifieds/detail.php?id=838083

On the SHOs one sem is dated Sept 1950, and the other March 1952.

I've acquired a could more SHOs since I finished that set and *may* have another '52 date coded one that would make a better match to the 3/52 one. But it's not restored yet.
_________________
John Henry

'57 Deluxe
'56 Single Cab

[IN2VWS]

I agree with John, there is evidence that in April 1953, ovals still had ribbed semaphores. Here are pics from Peter Keetmans book titled 'Volkswagenwerk 1953'.

_________________
( ⫏ ⫐ )
(ọ\ ¡ /ọ)¹⁹⁵⁴ ¹⁹⁵¹
(⦷ ⥢ Ĭ ⥤ ⦷) 𝗞_𝗔_𝗥_𝗠_𝗔_𝗡_𝗡 𝓖𝓱𝓲𝓪¹⁹⁵⁶
⨴⨵--⊗--⨴⨵ 𝕊ℙ𝟚¹⁹⁷³
𝟵_𝟭_𝟰¹⁹⁷³

[ZwitterND]

John, I can't find a date on the catalog but diagrams show zwitters. Strange part is it will show parts I thought came on earlier models such as cable brakes & lever shocks.

_________________
Bill

[D. Haviland]

Those parts catalogs have bolt type bindings and could have sections added as they were handed down to the new guy

[tazm]

[ZwitterND]

What is the difference, if any, between "grooved" and "ribbed"
_________________
Bill

[Bruce]

One is SHO, the other is SWF.
_________________

[tazm]

3 grooved on the left , and 4 ribbed on the right !

[john7]

[Dropped Metal Customs]

We learn something new everyday on these forums
i have smooth semaphores on my zwitter too im not a purest so i dont worry to much they still look cool and get alot of looks when im driving around, its amazing how many people have never seen or even know about semaphores
ive even been asked why i put that window in the back lol
_________________
BUSDROPPINGBEAMNARROWINGSTEERINGBOXRAISING"C"NOTCHINGRUSTREPAIRINGBEETLEDROPPING
@DroppedMetalCustoms

[geneL3c]

I'd like to thank everyone for answering all the questions I ever had about correct semaphores , except one ! How do you keep people from trying to pull the semaphores out to show their asshole buddies the " funny turn signals " ? Seems every time I walk away from my '50 Standard , some clown " expert " has to show how smart they are , and start to pull the trafficators out , usually managing to f**k them up !

[ZwitterND]

Sharpen the very end where they grab it? Hook up an alarm to it? Wire it to shock them? Smear something smelly on them? oops have I opened a can of worms?
_________________
Bill

[66 dormi]

repaint your car black so they don't notice!!
_________________
DORMOBILE TOP WANTED!!!!
1978 westy daily driver
1960 panel camper project

Mini R53 bob the tomato

[johnshenry]

[geneL3c]

John , Got an extra crank handle you'd care to part with ? I must live in some sort of dumb zone , I also had beer poured on the roof at the same place ( Friday cruise night at the local crab shack ! ) , but they left my wife's Packard alone , parked right next door ? Rodney Dangerfield was right !

[ZwitterND]

I remember one of my first experiences driving my zwitter in CT in 1975. After making a lane change on I 94 I noticed out of the corner of my eye a car pulling ever so close to me, not passing but keeping pace with me. He moved closer swerving away & then closer. I finally got the nerve to look. Here the guy was leaning over rolling down his passenger window with one hand steering then beckoning me to roll down my window. You can imagine my fear being 19 and some crazed old guy shouting and swerving at 55mph "Hey what year is that and what are those things" (pointing to the semifores). I told him, but what I wanted to say is "get the F#$% away from my car you crazy old fart. Ironically, I am that crazy old fart now when I see a nice car.
_________________
Bill